Diversity in People, Programs, and Ideas

On the Road With the College of Agriculture

The two groups of students met for the first time as dawn broke over the UA's Old Main flagpole on Monday, January 5. Nineteen College of Agriculture student ambassadors boarded a bus with 19 Monterrey Tech students from Ciudad Obregon, Sonora, Mexico, to begin a three-day tour of Arizona agriculture.

Another bus held the College of Agriculture administrative group and nearly two dozen new faculty and staff; Mike Gottfredson, UA vice president; Lynne Wood, UA attorney; Dick Roberts, UA chief budget officer; Ron Smith, UA controller; and several U.S. congressional aides. The New Faculty Tour of the College of Agriculture was on its way for the ninth consecutive year.

Each year, the College of Agriculture promotes this tour for two reasons: 1) it gives new faculty a chance to see the diversity of agriculture in Arizona and the importance of the college's outreach efforts and 2) it offers alumni, producers, ranchers and community dignitaries an opportunity to see the new faculty who are just beginning their work at The University of Arizona.

This year, however, something new was added, thanks to a grant from the University of Arizona Diversity Action Council. A group of students accompanied by a director and Joaquin Tena, the president of the Instituto Technologico y de Estudios Superiores de Monterrey (ITESM), had journeyed eight hours north the day before to join the Arizona students in the first student exchange to establish a new relationship between the two universities.

Over the next three days the students would learn about agriculture, each other, and how to sing "Ninety Nine Bottles of Beer" in both English and Spanish. Dairy farms, lettuce fields, pecan orchards, citrus packing plants, and feedlots with over 125,000 head of cattle provided the backdrop for many student and faculty interactions during the three-day period.

More than 430 people attended the community dinner in Yuma the first evening and nearly 200 were in Phoenix the following night.

UA President Peter Likins joined the group in Yuma, where he met resident alumni, agricultural producers and local leaders the first evening. He emphasized the importance of border exchanges such as this one and the relationships that can occur when our students begin to think about borderless joint ventures for future international business. President Likins said he joined ITESM President Joaquin Tena in solidifying this relationship.

"This has been one of the best experiences of my student years here at the University of Arizona," said Abigail Pasos, a UA senior in agricultural and resource economics, and program coordinator for the tour. "I was able to bring together my love for the Mexican international business culture, agriculture and students from both sides of the border. It has been a great experience."

Eugene Sander, College of Agriculture dean and UA vice provost, agreed.

"This is the first year we have taken students on our tour but we will never go again without them," he said. "They provided that spark of enthusiasm and curiosity that enhanced everyone's time on tour. Having the ITESM students was also a plus for the future of agriculture in both countries."

Research on Men and Women as Leaders

Despite such role models as U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright and Attorney General Janet Reno, Americans have difficulty perceiving women as leaders--even when they demonstrate the same leadership behaviors as men, according to American Psychological Association's newspaper, Monitor. The August 1997 issue summarizes recent research on men and women as leaders.

When women clearly demonstrate strength and decisiveness as characteristics, employers still don't think they are as capable as men of holding leadership positions.

Executive women see this kind of subtle stereotyping as the main barrier to their advancement to corporate leadership. They see their exclusion from the informal network of communication, which is enjoyed by many male leaders, as a second major obstacle. In contrast, CEOs see women's lack of general management and line experience as the biggest obstacle to their advancement.

Stereotypes also affect men in their careers. Prevailing beliefs are that men's value systems are biased toward enhancing the present system. They are subsequently hired to maintain the status quo. Men who don't fit that system of behavior are less likely to be hired.

The Communicator, Fall 1997

Cross-Cultural Do's

Provide plenty of background information when working with Germans. They have a saying, "You have to start with Charlemagne," which means they require detail and a historical perspective on issues before feeling comfortable making decisions.

Remember that the Japanese are interested in long-term relationships that generally are based on trust, friendship, service and quality, rather than price.

Remember to use formal titles with the French until you've known them for a considerable length of time. The quick familiarity of Americans can be offensive to them.

Realize that in Latin countries it isn't what you do that counts, but to whom you're related. Americans tend to rank each other by occupation, but Latin Americans will want to know who your father is.

Offer a gift when invited to a Japanese home. Gifts must not be lavish, but in good taste and nicely wrapped.

Feel free to make physical contact - a pat on the back, a long handshake or even a kiss on the cheek - with your associates in Europe and Latin America. These gestures are almost always acceptable in a business setting. On the other hand, in India and Pakistan, no type of touching is acceptable. People simply bow.

Dress conservatively in Japan and avoid cologne and perfume. They are not used in that country traditionally and could be offensive.

Cross-Cultural Don'ts

Don't ask a French Person, "Where do you live?" or "What do you do? It's similar to asking an American, "How much money do you make?"

Don't suggest casually to a German individual, "Let's get together for lunch sometime," unless you mean it. Taking the comment literally, the German is apt to take out a calendar to schedule a time.

Don't stand more than a foot away from a business associate from Saudi Arabia. Too much distance is a sign of rejection.

Don't expect your Latin American counterparts to stick to an agenda or start meetings exactly at the scheduled time. They're more flexible with time and regard it as a long-term commodity.

Don't say no to the Japanese. Because of their desire for saving face and maintaining harmony, Japanese people have an aversion to this word. To avoid being impolite, they'll either simply not respond, or they'll give an evasive answer such as, "It's very difficult."

Don't cross your legs or expose the heel of your foot during a business meeting in the Middle East. This gives the signal to your host that they're worthy of being stepped on.

Don't hold up your hand, palms outward, in Africa. Such a gesture is considered rude and inappropriate.

Note: These generalities may or may not be true for the groups represented. Each situation is different and must be judged independently.

Reprinted from Managing Diversity, January 1998

Book Review

Global Work, Bridging Distance, Culture and Time by Mary O'Hara-Devereaux and Robert Johansen provides a fresh approach to current critical issues in the world of work. The authors offer new, positive, and powerful perspectives on bridging distance, culture, and time in today's global economy. While the focus is global, the information in this text has direct application to our own home grown diversity factors.

Available from Jossey-Bass Publishers (800) 274-4434.

What's New

Diversity Issues in the Classroom is a video from Penn State University. It has four case studies, each dealing with a specific aspect of diversity in the classroom. Short dramatic vignettes are followed by panel discussions. Each segment is open-ended to facilitate live discussion:

Confronting Overt Racism - Addresses the question of what an instructor's responsibility is when confronted with overt racism in the classroom.

Gender Bias - A female student is constantly overlooked in class by her professor.

Diversity as Subject Matter - Women's Studies instructor loses control of class as the legitimacy of her discipline is called into question.

Instructor with Language Bias - Instructor insists Latino student has problem with English.

Available from Penn State University, $125, (800) 770-2111.

Vision:  To affect positive change in the CALS community by valuing differences and building respect.

The University of Arizona is an equal opportunity, affirmative action institution. The University does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age, disability, veteran status, or sexual orientation in its programs and activities.


Content Questions/Comments: Billye Foster (billye@cals.arizona.edu) or Steven Crofts (scrofts@cals.arizona.edu)
Last Updated:
05/16/2005